By: Dice Roofing Solutions 6 minutes read

Choosing the right roof is an essential decision for homeowners, with about 5 million in the U.S. facing this choice annually, whether replacing an old one or crowning a new one.

Among the myriad options, the two most popular are metal roofs and shingles. As the popularity of these modern roofing systems escalates, it’s crucial to weigh factors like cost-effectiveness, maintenance, and installation ease.

This blog will dig deep into the metal roof vs shingles debate, understand both pros and cons and offer insights to ensure you make an informed decision tailored to your needs.

What is a Metal Roof?

A metal roof is a durable roofing system made from metallic materials, offering superior longevity and protection against the elements. It stands out for its ease of maintenance and straightforward installation process, appealing to homeowners looking for a reliable, long-term solution.

Types of Metal Roofs

Various metal roofing options are suited to different aesthetic preferences and environmental conditions.

Here’s a closer look at some popular types:

Aluminum: Ideal for coastal homes, aluminum is lightweight, corrosion-resistant, and helps reduce cooling costs.
Stone-Coated Steel: Merges steel’s strength with a stone coat for severe weather resilience and diverse style.
Tin: Now a modern, coated steel, offering durability and a rustic appeal with eco-friendly benefits.
Zinc: Offers incredible durability, corrosion resistance, and a self-healing feature for minor scratches.
Copper: Boasts remarkable longevity and beauty, aging gracefully into a distinctive green patina.

Benefits and Drawbacks of Metal Roof

Here’s a closer look at the key advantages and potential downsides of choosing a metal roof for your home.

Pros

Durability: Metal roofs can last 40-70 years, significantly outlasting traditional materials, thanks to their resistance to decay, mildew, and insects.
Fire Resistance: Metal roofing is noncombustible, offering a high level of fire resistance, which can be crucial in areas prone to wildfires.
Low Maintenance: Unlike other roofing materials, metal roofs require minimal upkeep to maintain appearance and functionality over the years.
Eco-Friendly: Made from recycled materials and fully recyclable at the end of their life, metal roofs are a green choice for environmentally conscious homeowners.
Energy Efficiency: Metal roofs’ reflective qualities save cooling expenses by cooling your property by reflecting solar radiation heat rather than absorbing it.

Cons

Initial Cost: The upfront cost of metal roofing is higher than traditional materials, but its longevity can offset this over time.
Denting: Some metal roofs can dent from heavy hail or falling branches, though materials like copper and aluminum are more resistant.
Expansion and Contraction: As temperatures fluctuate, metal roofs expand and contract, necessitating installation methods that account for this movement.
Noise: Metal roofs can produce more noise than other varieties during periods of intense rain or hail, though this problem can be lessened with adequate insulation.

What are Shingles?

Shingles stand out as a highly favored modern roofing choice, celebrated for their remarkable versatility and cost-effectiveness. Available in various materials and hues, they seamlessly adapt to diverse architectural styles.

Shingles roofing fits a broad spectrum of homeowner preferences and budgetary considerations, making them a go-to option for residential roofing.

Types of Shingles

Shingles roofs vary widely in material, each offering unique benefits to homeowners:

Asphalt Shingles: The most common type, known for affordability and ease of installation.
Architectural Shingles: A premium asphalt shingle with a layered look, offering enhanced durability and aesthetic appeal.
Wood Shingles: Provide a natural, rustic appearance and are made from cedar, redwood, or pine.
Slate Shingles: Offer unmatched longevity and a distinctive, elegant appearance.

Benefits and Drawbacks of Shingles

Let’s explore what makes shingles a favored choice for many, alongside some considerations to remember.

Pros

Affordability: Asphalt shingles, in particular, are among the most cost-effective roofing options available.
Variety in Style: Shingles come in a wide range of colors and styles, making it easy to match your home’s aesthetic.
Ease of Installation: Shingles are easier and quicker to install than other roofing materials, reducing labor costs.
Repair and Maintenance: Damaged shingles can be easily replaced, simplifying repairs and maintenance.

Cons

Shorter Lifespan: Shingles generally have a shorter lifespan than metal roofing, often requiring replacement every 20 to 30 years.
Vulnerability to Weather: They can be more susceptible to damage from high winds, heavy rain, and hail compared to more durable materials like metal.
Maintenance: Shingles, especially wood, may require more maintenance to prevent mold, mildew, and decay.

Metal Roof vs Shingles (Key Comparisons)

Each option presents unique benefits and considerations in the debate of metal roofs vs shingles. Let’s explore how these two popular roofing materials stack against each other.

Cost Comparison Over Time

While initially more expensive, metal roofs ultimately provide savings through reduced maintenance and a longer lifespan. In contrast, though less costly upfront, shingles may lead to more significant long-term expenses due to the need for more frequent replacements and repairs.

Aesthetic and Design Considerations

Metal roofs offer a contemporary aesthetic with many styles, some mimicking shingles, to suit modern homes. Shingles provide traditional appeal with a vast selection of colors and textures, ensuring compatibility with various architectural designs.

Suitability for Various Climates

Metal roofs are highly resilient in extreme weather, making them suitable for various climates, from heavy snow to wildfires. Shingles perform best in moderate climates but are more vulnerable to damage from severe weather conditions like high winds and rain.

Resale Value Impact

Metal roofs can enhance a home’s resale value due to their longevity and energy efficiency. Shingles, while offering aesthetic appeal and widespread popularity, also contribute positively to a property’s marketability, albeit with a different value proposition.

Durability & Longevity

Durability and longevity are crucial considerations; metal roofs boast a lifespan of 40-70 years with minimal maintenance, significantly outlasting shingles, which typically need replacement every 20-30 years. This makes metal roofs a more sustainable option over time.

Installation Time

When handled by professionals familiar with the material, metal roof installations can be completed swiftly despite the complexity. Shingle roofs, known for their ease of installation, offer a quick and straightforward process, making them a time-efficient choice.

Best Option for You: Make Your Decision

Choosing between metal roofs and shingles is crucial for your home’s longevity and aesthetics. For those ready to take the next step, Dice Roofing Plus offers expert services in residential roofing, including metal and shingle options, roof repair, and more.

With our commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, you can confidently embark on your roofing project. Contact Dice Roofing Plus to enhance your home with durability and style, ensuring your choice meets all your needs.